CLOSING October 20th. ALL SALES FINAL. Store credit invalid after 10/20.
 

Speech & Debate

Take 25% off most new and used products, while supplies last!

Both speech and debate center around an activity that gets mentioned a lot in the U.S. but actually engaged in very seldom--dialogue. A good debater listens and responds intelligently to his opponent; a good public speaker establishes communication between himself or his group and whoever he's addressing.

It's all too common to watch debates between people so busy spouting their own opinion that their opponent goes unheard, or to listen to a speech so cluttered with platitudes and politically-correct language that it becomes meaningless. But you need not look too far back in history to find statesmen, academics and industry leaders able to clearly articulate their ideas in public forums without resorting to empty rhetoric or doctored statistics.

My kids aren't going into politics or economics, you might say. Why should they study speech and debate?

The fact is, most students would benefit greatly from focused study in these fields. Because while the public sphere is certainly the most obvious arena for putting these kinds of skills to use, the real benefit of speech and debate is to teach kids the arts of research, critical thinking, analysis, and effective communication.

Public speaking and debate aren't exactly the same thing. Traditionally, public speaking involves a single orator, while debate involves at least two speakers approaching one subject from different angles. There are some public speaking clubs still operating in the United States, but typically debate attracts the higher number of students, and really debate is simply a more advanced form of public speaking.

College debate clubs typically focus on parliamentary debate and moot court; these are fairly specialized law- and politics-based forms of debate and adhere to strict rules of form in addition to requiring high standards of content. Most high school students, however, practice either policy or Lincoln-Douglas debate.

Policy debate (or cross-examination debate, or team debate) centers around a resolution (such as, Resolved: That the United States should outlaw orangutangs) which students argue for or against using research and their own wits. Lincoln-Douglas is similar, except that it centers more broadly around a moral or idealist issue, like abortion or euthenasia.

Debaters have been known to obsess over their research, to spend unwarranted hours at the public library, to haul all their findings around in a big plastic box (okay, most of them do that), and to slick their hair to the side with Dep gel. But that doesn't mean you shouldn't get your kids involved. A good debater won't just snow the opposition with hard evidence; she'll learn both sides of the issue thoroughly enough to become conversant (often students are called on to defend both sides), and spend significant time cohering everything into a manageable and communicable position.

Public speaking is less rule-based than debate, doesn't require as much familiarity with opposing views, and generally involves only a single orator as opposed to speakers arguing back and forth. As a result, public speakers generally spend more time on rhetorical details, ensuring their speech will be both stirring and aesthetically pleasing. Francis Bacon thought young people should be trained in public speaking because it taught them how to remain calm under public observation.

There are more personal ways debate can improve students beyond the intellect. Intelligent students who struggle to express themselves will learn to present information and ideas clearly and effectively; blow-hards with a penchant for gabbing will be forced to remain succinct and support what they say with evidence and logic; and moderate students will refine their abilities to make a good argument in a cogent and (as Jon Winslow famously said) winsome manner.

All this talk of argument may put some parents off. But it isn't argument of the kind engaged in by combative siblings; it's argument of the old fashioned kind, the respectful exchange of ideas in a spirit of equality. This really is the whole crux of education--if students don't learn to communicate and defend their own beliefs, they haven't learned anything of much use. In fact, this is the point on which Christian education hinges, since it is the apologetic task of every believer to maintain a ready defense for those who challenge his faith.

There are local and national debate and public speaking leagues open specifically to home schoolers. Generally these mix hands-on practice with actual instruction, so kids aren't just groping in the dark. They have assignments, debate tournaments, and constructive criticism.

Genuine exchange of ideas seems to be an increasingly lost art, but if a society is to function as a free democratic republic, such exchange must be central to its framework. Even more important, as Christians we need to be able to understand opposing views, measure them against our orthodox beliefs, and respond to them intelligently and compassionately. Training in debate and public speaking can help us achieve both objectives.

Review by C. Hollis Crossman
C. Hollis Crossman used to be a child. Now he is a husband and father, teaches adult Sunday school in his Presbyterian congregation, and likes weird stuff. He might be a mythical creature, but he's definitely not a centaur.Read more of his reviews here.

 

Did you find this review helpful?
Parent Categories
Speech & Debate
Subcategories
Local Debate
CCN
Christian Communicators Northwest
BHDC
Beaverton Homeschool Debate Club
National League
NCFCA
National Christian Forensics Communication Association
STOA
Students Learning and Growing through Speech and Deabte
Related Links
Public Speaking - Wikipedia Article
Public Speaking Tips
GreatDebate.net
A resource for forensics competitors and more.
Argumentation and Debate
from CHOCBoard.net
70 Items found Print
Accurate Communication
by William F. McCart
from Educators Publishing Service
for 4th-6th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Argumentation & Debate - DVD
by Christy Shipe
from Home School Legal Defense Association
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Art of Apologetics
by Karen Kovaka
from Communicators for Christ
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Art of Interpretation
by Nicholas R. Elledge
from Communicators for Christ
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Art of Platform Speaking
by Michele Hop
from Communicators for Christ
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Art of Practical Debate
by Grace Lichlyter, Teresa M. Moon
1st edition from Communicators for Christ
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Art of Value Debate
by Matt Pitchford, Teresa M. Moon
1st edition from Communicators for Christ
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Beginning Public Speaking - Interactive Video Curriculum
by Teresa Moon
from Communicators for Christ
for 2nd-6th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Beginning Public Speaking - Starter Set
by Teresa Moon
from Communicators for Christ
for 2nd-6th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Beginning Public Speaking - Student Workbook
by Teresa Moon
2nd edition from Communicators for Christ
for 2nd-6th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Beginning Public Speaking - Teacher's Edition
by Teresa Moon
3rd edition from Communicators for Christ
for 2nd-6th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Classical Rhetoric for the Modern Student
by Edward P. J. Corbett, Robert J. Connors
4th edition from Oxford University
for 9th-Adult
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Classical Rhetoric through Structure and Style
by Adam Muller
from Institute for Excellence in Writing
for 9th-12th grade
in IEW Advanced Materials (Location: B16-03E)
Classical Rhetoric with Aristotle
by Martin Cothran
from Memoria Press
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Classical Rhetoric with Aristotle - DVD Set
by Martin Cothran
from Memoria Press
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Classical Rhetoric with Aristotle - Package
by Martin Cothran
from Memoria Press
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Classical Rhetoric with Aristotle - Teacher Key
by Martin Cothran
from Memoria Press
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Essential American
by Jackie Gingrich Cushman
from Regnery Publishing, Inc.
for 9th-Adult
in 18th Century Literature (Location: CLT-18C)
Everyday Debate & Discussion
by Shelly Johnson
from Classical Academic Press
for 7th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Everyday Debate & Discussion - Teacher Guide
by Shelly Johnson
Tch from Classical Academic Press
for 7th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Figures of Speech
by Arthur Quinn
from Hermagoras Press
for 9th-12th grade
in Grammar Reference (Location: B15-02A)
From Playpen to Podium
by Jeff Myers
from Noble Publishing
for 2nd-8th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Great Speeches By African Americans
by Brian Daley
from Dover Publications
for 10th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
How to Give a Speech
by Margaret Ryan
Revised Edition from Franklin Watts
for 7th-12th grade
in Clearance: Language Arts (Location: ACL-LAN)
Indian Oratory
by W. C. Vanderwerth
from University of Oklahoma Press
for 11th-12th grade
in Clearance: Literature (Location: ACL-LIT)
Intro to Policy Debate - Book Package
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Introduction to Aristotle
by Aristotle
from McGraw-Hill
for 9th-12th grade
in Ancient Literature (Location: CLT-ANC)
Introduction to Policy Debate
by Christy Shipe
5th edition from Home School Legal Defense Association
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Jeub's Guide to Home School Speech & Debate
by Chris Jeub
4th edition from Monument Publishing
for 7th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Jeub’s Guide to Speech & Debate
by Chris Jeub
5th edition from Institute for Excellence in Writing
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Journey
by Peter Kreeft
from InterVarsity Press
for 9th-Adult
in Philosophy (Location: C08-01B)
Letter from Birmingham Jail / I Have a Dream Speech
by Martin Luther King, Jr.
from Perfection Learning
for 10th-Adult
in Civil Rights Movement (1955-1968) (Location: B01-27A)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Book 1
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Book 2
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Book 3
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Book 4
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Book 5
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Boxed Set
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Lifepac: Essentials of Communication - Teacher's Guide
from Alpha Omega Publications
for 9th-12th grade
in Clearance: Language Arts (Location: ACL-LAN)
Mock Trial Notebook Case #1
from Classical Conversations
for 7th-9th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Mock Trial Notebook Case #2
from Classical Conversations
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Mock Trial Notebook Case #3
from Classical Conversations
for 9th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
My Fellow Americans
by Michael Waldman
Har/Com from Sourcebooks
for 9th-12th grade
in American Presidency (Location: B03-00E)
Office of Assertion
by Scott F. Crider
1st edition from Intercollegiate Studies Institute
for 9th-Adult
in Writing Instruction (Location: B16-04D)
Painless Speaking
by Mary Elizabeth
2nd edition from Barron's Educational Series, Inc.
for 4th-6th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Persuasions
by Doug Wilson
from Canon Press
for 9th-Adult
in Beginning Christian Apologetics (Location: C04-03C)
Rhetoric
by Aristotle
from Dover Publications
Ancient Greek Philosophy for 9th-Adult
in Ancient Literature (Location: CLT-ANC)
Rhetoric Alive Book 1
by Alyssan Barnes
from Classical Academic Press
for 10th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Rhetoric Alive Book 1 - Teacher's Edition
by Alyssan Barnes
from Classical Academic Press
for 10th-12th grade
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
Rhetoric Companion
by N.D. Wilson & Douglas Wilson
from Canon Press
in Speech & Debate (Location: APO-03B)
12